Ideal Substrate pH Ranges for Gourmet Mushrooms

Most cultivated gourmet mushrooms grow best in slightly acidic substrates. Maintaining the proper substrate pH is important for healthy mycelial growth and fruiting. Generally, a pH between ~5.0 and 6.5 is ideal for many species, although some, especially Pleurotus (also known as oysters), can tolerate and even prefer a more neutral or mildly alkaline substrate. A proper pH not only optimizes mushroom growth but also helps suppress contaminants, such as Trichoderma molds, which often thrive in neutral pH environments. Therefore, keeping Shiitake substrates acidic or Oyster substrates at a temporarily high pH during pasteurization can be beneficial. Below is a comprehensive table of major gourmet mushrooms, their scientific names, ideal substrate pH ranges, and additional notes on substrate preferences and pH sensitivity.

Ideal pH Ranges by Species

Common Name

Scientific Name

Ideal Substrate pH Range

Notes

Lion’s Mane

Hericium erinaceus

5.5–6.5 (slightly acidic)

Thrives on hardwood sawdust substrates (often supplemented with bran). Tolerates a broad pH (reported growth from pH 5 up to 9), but shows optimal mycelial development around pH ~6.

Blue Oyster

Pleurotus columbinus

6.0–8.0 (neutral to mildly basic)

A cold-loving Pleurotus (oyster) variety. Grows aggressively on straw or sawdust; tolerates higher pH than many fungi. Substrates are often lime-treated (raising pH to ~8) to reduce contaminants, which Pleurotus can withstand.

Pink Oyster

Pleurotus djamor

5.5–6.5 (slightly acidic)

Grows on a wide range of agro-waste (straw, sawdust, etc.). Prefers acidic conditions; less tolerant of high pH than other oysters. Substrate pH in the mid-5 to 6 range optimizes colonization and fruiting.

Shiitake

Lentinula edodes

5.5–6.5 (slightly acidic)

Traditionally grown on hardwood logs or sawdust blocks. Requires an acidic substrate – shiitake mycelium thrives around a pH of 5–6 and is sensitive to alkaline conditions (lime is usually not added to shiitake substrates). Gypsum (calcium sulfate) can be used to provide calcium without raising the pH.

Chestnut

Pholiota adiposa

5.5–6.5 (slightly acidic)

Grows well on sterilized hardwood sawdust with supplements. Similar to shiitake, it prefers a mildly acidic substrate. Generally sensitive to pH swings; keep in mid-5 to mid-6 range for best yields.

Cordyceps

Cordyceps militaris

5.0–7.0 (acidic to neutral)

Commonly cultivated on grain-based media (e.g., rice). An initial slightly acidic pH (~5.5–6) promotes mycelial growth and cordycepin production. Broad tolerance up to neutral pH ~7.0, but avoid extremes for optimal yields.

King Oyster

Pleurotus eryngii

6.0–7.0 (slightly acidic to neutral)

Grows on hardwood sawdust (often supplemented with bran or soy hulls). Favors near-neutral conditions – neither too acidic nor too alkaline. Maintaining pH ~6–7 supports vigorous mycelium and high yields.

Golden Oyster

Pleurotus citrinopileatus

5.0–7.0 (acidic to neutral)

“Yellow Oyster” mushroom; similar cultivation to other Pleurotus. Grows well in slightly acidic to neutral substrate. Optimal mycelial growth has been reported around a pH of ~6.0, with good tolerance from pH 5 to 7. However, extremely alkaline conditions are not recommended.

Enoki (Enokitake)

Flammulina velutipes

5.0–6.0 (acidic)

Typically grown in sterilized sawdust bottles. Prefers an acidic substrate; commercial enoki substrates are often buffered to a pH of around 5–6. A slightly acidic environment is crucial for proper mycelial growth and the formation of the long, thin fruiting bodies.

Maitake (Hen-of-the-Woods)

Grifola frondosa

5.5–6.0 (slightly acidic)

Grows on supplemented hardwood sawdust blocks or buried wood chips. Optimal pH is in the mid-5s. Substrates are typically buffered to a pH of ~5.5–6.0 for optimal mycelial growth and fruiting. Maitake is sensitive to overly high pH levels; keep it at a moderately acidic pH.

Nameko

Pholiota nameko 

(P. microspora)

~5.5–6.5 (slightly acidic)

Often cultivated on hardwood sawdust with supplements (or inoculated into logs). Performs best in mildly acidic conditions, similar to other wood-loving mushrooms. Some growers add gypsum (Calcium sulfate) to stabilize pH without significantly increasing it. Avoid high pH, as nameko mycelium prefers a pH range of ~5–6.

Pioppino (Black Poplar)

Agrocybe aegerita

6.0–6.5 (slightly acidic)

A wood-loving mushroom commonly grown on pasteurized straw or enriched sawdust. Ideal pH is around neutral-slightly acidic (~6–6.5). Substrate can be buffered with a bit of lime to ~6.5, but overly alkaline conditions (>7) are avoided. Pioppino mycelium is relatively hardy but grows fastest in the 6–6.5 range.

Reishi (Lingzhi)

Ganoderma lucidum

5.5–6.0 (slightly acidic)

A medicinal polypore grown on hardwood sawdust blocks or logs. Prefers mildly acidic substrates; optimal mycelial growth is reported around pH 5.5–6.0. Reishi can tolerate a bit outside this range, but strongly acidic (<5) or alkaline (>7) substrates will hinder growth.

Turkey Tail

Trametes versicolor

4.0–6.0 (acidic)

A resilient wood-decomposer that thrives in acidic conditions. Optimal pH for mycelial growth is around 4–6. Notably, T. versicolor exhibits broad pH tolerance, with some studies observing good growth even at neutral to pH 8. For cultivation, maintaining the substrate at an acidic pH (~pH 5) helps suppress competitors and supports vigorous growth.

 

The above ranges are drawn from cultivation manuals, peer-reviewed studies, and extension resources. Generally, maintaining a substrate pH in the range of 5.5 to 6.5 will suit most gourmet mushrooms. Oysters (Pleurotus spp.) are an exception in their ability to tolerate higher pH levels, which is often exploited during pasteurization. Adjust the pH cautiously using buffering additives (such as gypsum or lime), and always monitor, as extreme pH adjustments can harm the mushroom mycelium or invite contaminants. Each species has its nuances, but a slightly acidic substrate is a safe starting point for most gourmet mushroom cultivation.

Back to blog